Choosing the right pool type is a critical decision that impacts your budget, backyard space, and long term enjoyment. From quick install above ground options to luxurious in ground designs, each pool type offers unique benefits and challenges. This blog breaks down the types of pools, compares installation processes, costs, and maintenance needs, and helps you decide which style aligns with your lifestyle and goals.
1. Above Ground Pools: Affordable and Quick to Install
When it comes to types of pools, above-ground options stand out for their affordability, speed, and versatility. These temporary structures, typically constructed from steel, resin, or aluminum, are installed atop the ground rather than excavated, making them ideal for homeowners seeking quick summer fun without long term commitments. Below, we break down installation timelines, costs, pros, and cons to help you decide if this best pool type fits your needs.
Installation Time & Cost: Fast and Budget Friendly
- Installation Time: 1 ,3 days (vs. weeks/months for in-ground pools).
- Steps: Level the ground, assemble the frame, install the liner, and fill with water.
- Pool Installation Cost:
- Basic Kits: $1,500-$5,000 (12-24 ft round/oval).
- Premium Models: $6,000–$10,000+ (includes decking, upgraded filtration).
Cost Factors:
- Decking: Adds $1,500-$5,000 (composite or wood).
- Location: Sloped yards may require grading ($500-$2,000).
Pros & Cons: Weighing Your Options
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| ✅ Low upfront cost | ❌ Shorter lifespan (10–15 yrs) |
| ✅ Portable (disassemble/move) | ❌ Limited customization |
| ✅ Minimal site prep | ❌ Less durable in harsh weather |
| ✅ DIY-friendly assembly | ❌ Lower resale value |
Maintenance Needs: Simpler but Steady
Above ground pools require less upkeep than in-ground types but still demand regular care:
- Daily: Skim debris, check chlorine levels (1-3 ppm).
- Weekly: Vacuum floors, scrub walls to prevent algae.
- Seasonal: Winterize with a cover and antifreeze ($50-$200).
Annual Maintenance Cost: $500,$1,000 (chemicals, repairs, water).
Above Ground vs. In Ground Pools: Quick Comparison
| Factor | Above-Ground | In-Ground |
|---|---|---|
| Installation Time | 1–3 days | 6 weeks–6 months |
| Cost | $1,500–$10,000 | $30,000–$100,000+ |
| Lifespan | 10–15 years | 20–50+ years |
| Customization | Limited shapes/sizes | Fully customizable |
Best For: Who Should Choose Above-Ground?
- Budget-Conscious Families: Ideal for those prioritizing upfront savings.
- Renters: Portable design suits non permanent homes.
- Temporary Needs: Perfect for short-term use (…, 3–5 years).
Real Life Example: A Georgia family installed a $4,000 18-ft resin pool with a DIY deck, enjoying summers without the $50,000 price tag of an in-ground build.
Key Takeaways
Above-ground pools excel in affordability and speed but lack the longevity and luxury of fiberglass pools or concrete pools. They’re a pragmatic choice for temporary setups or budget-focused buyers, though pool installation comparisons show in-ground options offer higher ROI and customization.
Note Tip: Opt for resin over steel frames they resist rust and last longer in humid climates like Georgia.
2. In Ground Pools: Permanent Luxury & Installation Comparisons
In ground pools are the gold standard for homeowners seeking a permanent, customizable backyard oasis. Built directly into the ground, they offer unparalleled durability and design flexibility. Below, we dissect the three primary types of in ground pools concrete, fiberglass, and vinyl liner detailing their installation processes, costs, and long-term value. We’ll also compare them to above-ground options to help you identify the best pool type for your budget and lifestyle.
A. Concrete Pools: Ultimate Customization
Installation Time: 3,6 months
Cost: $50,000-$100,000+
Pros:
- Fully Customizable: Design any shape, size, or depth (…, infinity edges, beach entries).
- Durability: Lasts 50+ years with proper maintenance.
- Luxury Appeal: Ideal for high-end homes in markets like Atlanta or Savannah.
Cons:
- High Maintenance: Requires acid washing every 2,3 years ($500-$1,500) and replastering every 10,15 years ($10,000+).
- Long Installation: Excavation, steel rebar setup, and curing add months to the timeline.
Best For: Owners wanting a bespoke design and willing to invest in upkeep.
B. Fiberglass Pools: Low Maintenance Luxury
Installation Time: 2,4 weeks
Cost: $40,000-$85,000
Pros:
- Quick Install: Pre-molded shells dropped into excavated sites.
- Smooth Surface: Gelcoat finish resists algae, reducing chemical use by 30%.
- Low Maintenance: No resurfacing needed; occasional pH balancing suffices.
Cons:
- Size/Shape Limits: Choose from pre made designs (typically 10,40 ft).
- Transport Challenges: Oversized shells may require crane access.
Best For: Busy families prioritizing ease and quick installation.
C. Vinyl Liner Pools: Budget-Friendly Customization
Installation Time: 4,6 weeks
Cost: $30,000-$60,000
Pros:
- Softer Surface: Smooth vinyl is gentle on feet.
- Custom Shapes: Flexible liners accommodate curves or unique layouts.
- Lower Upfront Cost: Cheapest in-ground option.
Cons:
- Liner Replacements: Required every 7,10 years ($3,000_ $5,000).
- Vulnerability: Sharp objects (toys, pets) can puncture liners.
Best For: Mid budget buyers seeking in ground customization without concrete’s cost.
3. Pool Installation Comparisons: Time, Cost, and Effort
| Pool Type | Installation Time | Installation Cost | Annual Maintenance Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Above-Ground | 1–3 days | $1,500–$10,000 | $500–$1,000 |
| Concrete (In-Ground) | 3–6 months | $50,000–$100,000+ | $1,500–$2,500 |
| Fiberglass (In-Ground) | 2–4 weeks | $40,000–$85,000 | $500–$1,200 |
| Vinyl Liner (In-Ground) | 4–6 weeks | $30,000–$60,000 | $1,000–$1,800 |
Key Takeaways from the Data
- Speed vs. Customization: Fiberglass offers the fastest in ground install (2,4 weeks), while concrete’s 3,6-month timeline allows full design freedom.
- Budget Considerations:
- Abov ground pools are 10x cheaper than in-ground options.
- Vinyl liners offer the lowest in-ground entry cost ($30k) but long term expenses from replacements.
Maintenance Demands:
- Fiberglass is the easiest/cheapest to maintain.
- Concrete demands the most upkeep (and cost) over time.
Cost vs. Value: Which In Ground Pool Reigns Supreme?
- Fiberglass Pools: Highest ROI (10,15%) due to low maintenance and quick resale appeal.
- Concrete Pools: Preferred in luxury markets for custom designs but require significant upkeep.
- Vinyl Liner Pools: Mid-range ROI (5,8%), ideal for mid-budget buyers wanting in ground perks.
Regional Tip: In humid climates like Georgia, fiberglass resists algae growth better than concrete or vinyl.
Why Choose In Ground Over Above Ground?
- Aesthetics: Seamlessly integrates with landscaping and hardscaping.
- Durability: Built to last decades vs. above-ground’s 10-15 year lifespan.
- Home Value: Adds 5,15% to resale value vs. above-ground’s minimal impact.
Case Study: A Marietta, GA, homeowner installed a $65,000 fiberglass pool, increasing their home’s value by $95,000.
Final Considerations
- Space: In ground pools require larger yards (500+ sq. ft).
- Permits: All in ground pools need permits ($500-$2,000 in Georgia).
- Climate: Fiberglass and vinyl handle freeze-thaw cycles better than concrete.
By comparing pool installation cost, timelines, and long-term demands, you can choose a pool that aligns with your budget, lifestyle, and backyard vision.
Ready to explore in ground options? Request a free quote from Georgia’s top rated pool builders!
4. Cost vs. Value: Which Pool Type Offers the Best ROI?
When investing in a pool, balancing upfront costs with long term value is critical. While some pool types offer quick enjoyment, others deliver significant returns in home equity and buyer appeal. Below, we analyze the ROI, maintenance demands, and longevity of above ground, fiberglass, concrete, and vinyl liner pools to help you maximize your investment.
ROI Breakdown by Pool Type
1. Above-Ground Pools: Short-Term Fun, Minimal ROI
- ROI: 0-5%
- Why? Viewed as temporary additions, above ground pools rarely boost resale value. Buyers may even request their removal.
- Best Use: Renters, budget-focused families, or those planning to relocate within 5,10 years.
- Case Study: A $5,000 above-ground pool added $3,000 to a Georgia home’s value but cost $1,200 to dismantle before sale.
2. Fiberglass Pools: High ROI with Low Effort
- ROI: 10–15%
- Why? Buyers love their low maintenance, sleek look, and quick installation. Popular in fast-moving markets like Florida and Texas.
- Cost to Value: A $60,000 fiberglass pool can add $75,000-$90,000 to home value in high-demand areas.
- Pro Tip: Pair with saltwater systems for higher buyer appeal.
3. Concrete Pools: Luxury Appeal, Moderate ROI
- ROI: 5–10%
- Why? Custom designs (infinity edges, spas) attract luxury buyers but require costly upkeep.
- Regional Variance: In affluent markets like Beverly Hills or Miami, ROI can hit 15% for high-end builds.
- Example: A $100,000 concrete pool with a waterfall added $120,000 to a Naples, FL, home’s sale price.
4. Vinyl Liner Pools: Mid-Range Value
- ROI: 5-8%
- Why? Lower upfront cost than concrete/fiberglass, but liner replacements deter buyers.
- Cost Factor: A $40,000 vinyl pool may add $30,000-$35,000 in value but needs a $4,000 liner in 7 years.
Key ROI Takeaways
- In Ground vs. Above Ground: In ground pools boost value 5-15%; above-ground adds minimal equity.
- Maintenance Matters: Fiberglass’ low upkeep drives higher ROI than high-maintenance concrete.
- Regional Impact: ROI soars in warm climates (FL, CA, AZ) where pools are lifestyle essentials.
5. Maintenance and Longevity: What to Expect
Above-Ground Pools
- Annual Tasks: Check liner for wear, balance pH (7.2-7.6), winterize with a cover.
- Lifespan: 10,15 years (resin frames last longer than steel).
- Cost/Year: $500,$1,000 (chemicals, repairs, water).
Click for more information about Why Is My Swimming Pool pH Level So Important?
Fiberglass Pools
- Annual Tasks: Occasional pH balancing, vacuum debris, inspect gelcoat.
- Lifespan: 25-30+ years with minimal repairs.
- Cost/Year: $500–$1,200 (cheapest in-ground option).
Concrete Pools
- Annual Tasks: Acid wash every 2,3 years ($500-$1,500), replaster every 10-15 years ($10,000+).
- Lifespan: 50+ years with rigorous upkeep.
- Cost/Year: $1,500- $2,500 (highest maintenance).
Vinyl Liner Pools
- Annual Tasks: Inspect for punctures, clean liner, balance alkalinity.
- Lifespan: 15, 20 years (with 2, 3 liner replacements).
- Cost/Year: $1,000- $1,800 (spikes during liner replacement years).
Your Top Questions Answered
Which pool type is easiest to maintain?
Fiberglass pools win hands down. Their non porous gelcoat surface resists algae growth, slashing chemical use and scrubbing time. Unlike concrete, they don’t need acid washing or replastering.
Can I convert my above ground pool to in ground later?
Yes, but it’s not simple. You’ll need to:
- Remove the above-ground pool ($500-$2,000).
- Excavate the site ($3,000-$10,000).
- Install an in-ground pool ($30,000-$100,000).
Most homeowners opt to start fresh with in-ground construction.
What’s the cheapest pool installation option?
Above ground pools are the most affordable, with basic kits starting at $1,500. However, consider long term value:
- Above Ground: $1,500 upfront + $1,000/year maintenance = $11,500 over 10 years.
- Fiberglass: $60,000 upfront + $8,000 maintenance = $68,000 over 25 years (with higher ROI).
Final Cost vs. Value Comparison Table
| Pool Type | Installation Cost | Lifespan | Total 10-Year Cost | ROI |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Above-Ground | $1,500_$10,000 | 10_15 years | $11,500_$25,000 | 0-5% |
| Fiberglass | $40,000_$85,000 | 25+ years | $45,000_$97,000 | 10-15% |
| Concrete | $50,000_$100,000+ | 50+ years | $65,000_$125,000+ | 5-10% |
| Vinyl Liner | $30,000_$60,000 | 15_20 years | $40,000_$78,000 | 5-8% |
Why Your Pool Choice Matters
- Lifestyle: Frequent entertainers may prioritize concrete’s customization, while busy families lean toward fiberglass.
- Climate: In humid regions like Georgia, fiberglass resists algae; in colder areas, vinyl liners handle freeze thaw cycles better.
- Budget: Above-ground suits short-term needs, while in ground pays off for long-term owners.
Note Tip: Consult a Realtor® before installing. In markets like Tampa or Phoenix, a pool can be a dealbreaker; in colder regions, it may deter buyers.
Choosing the right pool involves weighing cost vs. value, maintenance, and regional trends. Fiberglass pools offer the best balance of ROI and ease, while concrete appeals to luxury buyers. Above-ground pools work for temporary needs but add little equity. Ready to dive in? Request a free consultation to explore options tailored to your budget and backyard vision.
Invest wisely your perfect pool is a splash away from boosting fun and home value!
No comment